Schrödinger’s Dissent: The Hybrid Authority of a Dissenting Opinion

47 Pages Posted: 14 Aug 2023

See all articles by Christina Frohock

Christina Frohock

University of Miami - School of Law

Date Written: August 9, 2023

Abstract

A dissenting opinion is the Schrödinger’s cat of authorities: both the law and not the law simultaneously. Courts and scholars often clarify that a dissenting opinion is persuasive rather than binding, presuming that a dissent persuades as primary authority. Emerging from the pen of a judge wearing a black robe and acting in an official capacity, a dissenting opinion exhibits the form of the law. Yet, beneath that lofty sheen, a dissent exhibits the substance of secondary authority. A dissenting judge opines on the case at hand for the inherent purpose of undercutting the law, providing a case law coda. This Article describes the traditional categories of authority, primary and secondary, and identifies the writer as a distinguishing feature. The Article then describes various types of judicial opinion as primary authority and argues that a dissenting opinion inhabits a hybrid category. With exceptional status comes exceptional opportunity. As primary authority, a dissent enjoys the same rhetorical leeway as other opinions; as secondary authority, a dissent is an untethered critique of the law. Over the years, dissenting opinions from the Supreme Court provide enduring examples of a dissent’s mix of primary and secondary authority.

Keywords: dissenting opinion, primary authority, secondary authority, Supreme Court, sovereignty

Suggested Citation

Frohock, Christina, Schrödinger’s Dissent: The Hybrid Authority of a Dissenting Opinion (August 9, 2023). Marquette Law Review, Vol. 107, Forthcoming , University of Miami Legal Studies Research Paper No. 4536243, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4536243

Christina Frohock (Contact Author)

University of Miami - School of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 248087
Coral Gables, FL 33146
United States

Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?

Paper statistics

Downloads
106
Abstract Views
325
Rank
449,640
PlumX Metrics