Addressing the Use of Rap Lyrics as Criminal Evidence

Abstract

The judicial bias against rap music is a growing contributor to systemic racism that must be ended before it causes any more damage. Whether because of personally held beliefs, latent cultural insensitivity, or a win-at-all-costs prosecutorial approach to criminal trials that promotes an appeal to those traits in jurors, prosecutors should be bound from using the Constitutionally protected speech and expression in rap lyrics as evidence against criminal defendants.

At an increasing frequency, courts across the country are making it known that they have no problem using a rapper’s lyrics against them in a criminal case. This practice is particularly egregious, not only because of its chilling effect on creativity but because it is specifically targeted against rap music and rap music alone; in other words, it is a practice targeted against Black defendants.

Congress now needs to enact law expressly upholding, again, freedom of expression, and preventing that expressive speech from being weaponized against the communities that rely on it to express themselves, to tell the stories of their communities, and to create, and recreate, identity.

Keywords: evidence, rap lyrics, criminal procedure, first amendment, free speech, artistic expression

JEL Classification: K14, K4