Entry Without Competition
IGIER Working Paper No. 245
33 Pages Posted: 12 Jan 2004
Date Written: November 2003
Abstract
This paper examines competition in a liberalized market, with reference to some key features of the natural gas industry. Each firm has a low (zero) marginal cost core capacity, due to long term contracts with take or pay obligations, and additional capacity at higher marginal costs. The market is decentralized and the firms decide which customers to serve, competing then in prices. We show that under both sequential and simultaneous entry, there is a strong incentive to segment the market: when take-or-pay obligations are still to be covered, entering and competing for the same customers implies low margins. If instead a firm is left as a monopolist on a fraction of the market, exhausting its obligation, it has no further incentive to enter a second market, where the rival will be monopolist as well. Hence, we obtain entry without competition. Antitrust ceilings do not prevent such an outcome while a wholesale pool market induces generalized competition and low margins in the retail segment.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Liberalization of Energy Markets in Europe and Italy
By Michele Polo and Carlo Scarpa
-
Will Oil Prices Decline Over the Long Run?
By Robert Kaufmann, Pavlos Karadeloglou, ...
-
Cost Savings from Generation and Distribution with an Application to Italian Electric Utilities
By Giovanni Fraquelli, Massimiliano Piacenza, ...
-
Take or Pay Contracts and Market Segmentation
By Michele Polo and Carlo Scarpa
-
Energy Markets and the Euro Area Macroeconomy
By Rolf Strauch, Aidan Meyler, ...
-
Petrodollars and Imports of Oil Exporting Countries
By Roland Beck and Annette Kamps
-
By Bettina Landau and Frauke Skudelny
-
Demand for Storage of Natural Gas in Northwestern Europe: Trends 2005-2030
By Felix Höffler and Madjid Kübler
-
Gas Storage Services and Regulation in Italy: A Delphi Analysis
By Monica Bonacina, Anna Creti, ...