The Return of Boy Scouts of America v. Dale

22 Pages Posted: 22 Mar 2024 Last revised: 30 Apr 2024

See all articles by Elizabeth Sepper

Elizabeth Sepper

University of Texas at Austin - School of Law

Date Written: February 20, 2024

Abstract

In 2000, the Supreme Court’s decision in Boy Scouts of America v. Dale seemed to upend the law of freedom of association. Fears surfaced that the right of expressive association would be “an easy trump of any antidiscrimination law” —and perhaps other regulations of conduct. Organizations from schools to employers, social service providers to unions, could mount constitutional claims against the inclusion of individuals unwanted because of their sex, sexuality, race, disability, or beyond.

Instead, lower courts read Dale narrowly. Expressive associational rights would, it seemed, be bounded by the facts of the case. Freedom of association would not override equality under the law.

The ground, however, is now shifting. This essay identifies a rapid and dramatic resurgence of expressive association claims. In a series of decisions, courts have begun to read Dale as broadly as commentators once feared. Indeed, they have gone further still, taking the right to expressive association far beyond its foundations in the membership of non-profit, non-commercial groups. Employers, commercial entities, and social services providers have notched recent wins on expressive association claims. Several decisions conclude that an employer becomes expressive simply by articulating a desire to discriminate. Others deny a state interest in requiring nondiscrimination in employment on the ground that dissenting employees can work elsewhere—a proposition that would dismantle all of labor and employment law.

The essay offers some tentative explanations of the recent successes of expressive association claims. It predicts that the Supreme Court’s compelled speech opinion in 303 Creative v. Elenis will further fuel expansion. The essay concludes with a call to scholars to pay attention to developments in the lower courts where doctrinal siloes no longer hold and the antiregulatory agenda of the conservative legal movement is fast developing.

Keywords: Association, LGBTQ rights, reproductive rights, First Amendment, 303 Creative, Dale, speech

Suggested Citation

Sepper, Elizabeth, The Return of Boy Scouts of America v. Dale (February 20, 2024). St. Louis University Law Journal, Vol. 68, 2024, U of Texas Law, Legal Studies Research Paper, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4723159

Elizabeth Sepper (Contact Author)

University of Texas at Austin - School of Law ( email )

727 East Dean Keeton Street
Austin, TX 78705
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
157
Abstract Views
555
Rank
375,827
PlumX Metrics