Examining Measures of Schizotypy for Gender and Racial Bias Using Item Response Theory and Differential Item Functioning

Abstract

Schizotypy involves schizophrenia-like traits and symptoms, with the Wisconsin Schizotypy Scales (WSS) being frequently used in previous research. There is some evidence that schizophrenia-spectrum symptom levels, including when using the WSS, might vary both by gender and by race and ethnicity. However, previous research has rarely examined to what extent the WSS show gender and racial bias. Further, this has not been previously examined for the Cognitive Slippage Scale, a measure of disorganized schizotypy. In this study, we examined biases for a subset of items from the WSS in a large sample of undergraduate students (n=21,829). Using item response theory to test for levels of differential item functioning (DIF), we found some evidence of problematic DIF for all scales, including for negative, positive, and disorganized schizotypy scales. There was evidence of problematic DIF especially by gender and for Black and Multiracial participants. Overall, the current results suggest that gender and/or racial bias on these scales should be an important consideration in using these scales and our results could have implications for assessment of schizophrenia-spectrum symptoms.

Note:
Funding Information: There was no funding agency for this research.

Declaration of Interests: All authors declare no competing interests.

Ethics Approval Statement: his study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University of Missouri. IRB approved project number is 1154997.

Keywords: Schizotypy, Gender Bias, Racial Bias, Assessment Bias, Item Response Theory, Differential Item Functioning