The Gendered Violence of Asylum Reporting Requirements

61 Pages Posted: 16 Feb 2024 Last revised: 31 May 2024

Date Written: February 13, 2024

Abstract

In the past two decades, some U.S. courts have created and imposed hardline, or “per se,” reporting requirements that bar protection to asylum applicants who did not first report persecution from non-state actors to the authorities before fleeing. These requirements provide no exceptions, even in the face of undisputed evidence that reporting would have been futile, dangerous, or even impossible. While prior legal scholarship has addressed the dangers of reporting requirements generally, this Article explores the unique burdens that these requirements place on applicants with gender-based claims.

This Article applies feminist theory and an interdisciplinary approach to explore the reasons why reporting is often futile, dangerous, or impossible for women and girls fleeing gender-based violence in Guatemala, Honduras, and El Salvador—three of the top countries of origin for applicants seeking protection in the United States. This Article contends that the same misogyny that fuels gender-based violence also infuses the very government structures charged with providing protection from that violence. It argues that when U.S. courts minimize or ignore an applicant’s reasons for not reporting gender-based violence, they condone and perpetuate the same violence that the applicant fled. By using both English- and Spanish-language sources and centering the voices and experiences of Latin American scholars and advocates from and in the focus countries, this Article also challenges the hegemony of U.S. government reports in establishing country conditions in U.S. asylum proceedings. For both reasons, this Article will provide an important contribution to refugees, academics, practitioners, and policymakers working to challenge the application of reporting requirements and to fortify gender-based refugee protections.

Keywords: immigration law, asylum law, law, immigration, asylum, feminism, gender, feminist theory, Latin America, Central America, Guatemala, Honduras, El Salvador, United States, gender violence, gendered violence, domestic violence, gender-based violence, administrative law, international law

JEL Classification: K37

Suggested Citation

Steadman McGowan, Amelia, The Gendered Violence of Asylum Reporting Requirements (February 13, 2024). Columbia Human Rights Law Review, Forthcoming, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4725793 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4725793

Amelia Steadman McGowan (Contact Author)

University of Arkansas School of Law ( email )

1045 W. Maple St.
Fayetteville, AR 72701
United States
4795756541 (Phone)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
41
Abstract Views
202
PlumX Metrics