Adapting Gingles & Retaining Voter Power: Applying the VRA to State Judicial Retention Elections
66 Pages Posted: 15 Apr 2024 Last revised: 28 Dec 2024
Date Written: March 14, 2024
Abstract
State supreme courts play a crucial yet overlooked role in our nation’s judiciary. They are also predominantly white. In states with judicial elections, this racial homogeneity suggests that voters of color may not have an equal opportunity to “elect representatives of their choice" as required by the Voting Rights Act. While federal courts frequently apply the VRA to judicial elections which resemble legislative and executive contests, those same tribunals have failed to protect voters of color in non-competitive judicial retention elections.
This failure is due in part to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Thornburg v. Gingles, which established three threshold requirements for plaintiffs in vote dilution cases. These factors, which focus on a given plaintiff’s ability to craft a majority-minority district within the relevant multi-member elected body, do little to aid courts in judicial retention election cases because Gingles presumes the existence of geographic districts and a choice between candidates. Judicial retention elections possess neither of those qualities. Despite Gingles' inapplicability, lower federal courts have often mechanically applied the Gingles factors in judicial retention cases, creating insurmountable hurdles for plaintiffs bringing claims. In contravention of basic legal principles, these decisions declare that there is a right, but no associated remedy.
This Article advances a new reading of Gingles in the judicial retention context, a reading that both aligns with existing U.S. Supreme Court caselaw and ensures that voters of color in judicial retention elections can obtain meaningful relief when denied the ability to select a representative of their choice.
Keywords: Gingles, Judicial Diversity, State Courts, Voting Rights Act, VRA
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Mazeitis, Jake, Adapting Gingles & Retaining Voter Power: Applying the VRA to State Judicial Retention Elections (March 14, 2024). 103 Nebraska Law Review ___ (2025) (forthcoming), Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4759582
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Feedback
Feedback to SSRN