The Cost-Effectiveness and Cost-Consequences of a School-Based Social Worker Intervention: A Within-Trial Economic Evaluation

Abstract

Schools are a significant source of referrals to Children’s Social Care (CSC) services. A within-trial economic evaluation estimated the cost-effectiveness of embedding social workers in schools in England (SWIS) compared to usual practice.  Two hundred and sixty-eight schools comprising 277,888 students were randomised. The primary outcome of the trial was section 47 enquiries (i.e. child protection referrals to CSC services). The economic evaluation estimated the incremental cost-effectiveness of SWIS in reducing section 47 enquiries. Micro-costing approaches assessed the cost of the social worker intervention and addressed variability in key unit costs. Mean differences in costs and outcomes were estimated, with bootstrap 95% confidence intervals and scaling to incidence rate ratios per 1000 students per year. No statistically significant differences between trial arms were identified for any outcomes, costs or cost-effectiveness over a 23-month follow-up. The probability that SWIS is cost-effective was estimated for a range of willingness to pay values. At threshold values of £1000, £10,000 and £20,000 were probabilities for cost-effectiveness were estimated as 1.3%, 1.1% and 6.1%. This means SWIS had a low probability of being cost-effective.

Keywords: Economic evaluation Cost-effectivenessChildren's social care