Speaking Through Others' Voices: Authorship, Originality, and Free Speech

128 Pages Posted: 8 Jan 2004

Abstract

The article examines a category of speech acts that I call speech selection judgments. These acts involve the appropriation or selection of speech originally created elsewhere (by another) and the secondary deployment of that material in another context by a person or entity different than the original creator. The practice is essentially citational, in the broad sense that one repeats the words, speech, message, or meaning of another, and yet claims governance and, often, ownership over the repetitive use.

The article explores the variety of forms such speech selection judgments take, the Supreme Court's varied and inconsistent treatment of such acts as speech protected by the First Amendment, and the theoretical justifications for viewing such acts as First Amendment speech. I conclude that the Supreme Court's decisions are often based on conceptions of First Amendment speech that sweep too broadly and threaten to include a limitless variety of acts within the First Amendment simply because they can be perceived to communicate a message.

In light of this, the article concludes that speech selection acts should be treated as protected First Amendment speech acts only when (1) a person makes a speech selection for purposes of expression; (2) the selected speech is adopted as an expression of the speech selector's own ideas or opinions; and (3) the selected expression is transformed in meaning or significance by the act of selection.

Keywords: Free speech,authorship,originality,republication,intellectual property

Suggested Citation

Bezanson, Randall P., Speaking Through Others' Voices: Authorship, Originality, and Free Speech. Wake Forest Law Review, Vol. 38, Winter 2003. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=479721

Randall P. Bezanson (Contact Author)

University of Iowa College of Law ( email )

Boyd Law Building
Iowa City, IA 52242
United States
319-335-9171 (Phone)
319-335-9098 (Fax)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
164
Abstract Views
1,323
rank
196,331
PlumX Metrics