In Search of the Origin of Original Sin Dissipation

Abstract

In this paper, we examine how, contrary to the ‘original sin’ hypothesis, emerging market economies have gained the ability to borrow abroad in their local currency. We empirically analyze the relationship of various economic variables with local currency debt and identify three crucial conditions for the capacity to borrow in local currency: institutional quality, sufficient depth in the domestic bond market, and adequate performance in inflation targeting. While trade and financial openness, and shares in JPMorgan Government Bond Index-Emerging Markets (GBI-EM) Index also appear to be influential, their associations with local currency debt are less clear. We conduct a similar empirical analysis on portfolio equity, which represents a safer form of external liability than foreign currency debt, and verify that the depth of the equity market plays a key role in attracting foreign capital to domestic equity markets. Finally, we propose a simple portfolio model based on the inelastic market hypothesis to explain the positive correlation between capitalmarket depth and the dissipation of original sin, which refers to the presence of more external liability in  the form of equity or local currency debt. In essence, our analysis suggests that emerging market economies with reasonably strong fundamentals are not necessarily reliant on foreign currency debt.

Keywords: Original Sin, Local Currency Debt, EmergingMarket