The Value of Private Safety Versus the Value of Public Safety

Abstract

In this study we report an attempt to measure the WTP of car owners for a reduction of the probability of being killed in a traffic accident. One group of respondents is offered a safety device to be installed in their car, while another group is offered a public safety program (improved road quality) which results in the same size risk reduction. In terms of the value of a statistical life, our results are very reasonable. Moreover, there is a strong positive correlation between the magnitude of the WTP for the private safety device and the risks a respondent faces in traffic. However, the WTP for the private safety device is higher than the WTP for the public safety measure. Drawing on a model developed by Jones-Lee (1991), we show that a pure altruist may, but need not, be willing to pay more for a private risk reduction than for a uniform risk reduction of the same magnitude. This is also true for a wealth-focused altruist. Still, our empirical results are surprising, and further empirical research seems warranted.

JEL Classification: D61, D91, H51, I10, I12