The efficient enforcement challenge of secured transactions law reforms in civil law systems-self-help repossession, strict foreclosure, and other methods for the acceleration of enforcement of security interests †

51 Pages Posted:

See all articles by Tibor Tajti (Thaythy)

Tibor Tajti (Thaythy)

Central European University-Private University, Vienna, Austria

Date Written: October 03, 2024

Abstract

Although the forging of an efficient system for enforcement of security interest is one of the central expectations of secured transaction law reforms in civil law systems, the results hardly give reason for satisfaction. As the reforms tend to be supported and influenced by various international organizations' projects (especially the World Bank, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law, and the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law), most out-of-court methods of enforcement of security interests have played a central role. Yet due to civil law's general hostility towards self-help as such, either the introduction of the concept has been rejected or the local limited-reach kin have been merely 'paper tigers'. Similarly, although security interests on several types of collateral (accounts, investment property) or on the workhorse of the English financial system-the floating charge-have also been enforced extrajudicially (save the exceptions), little attention has been attributed to these enforcement modalities. The same applies to strict foreclosure in civil law systems still being prohibited, or restricted, and thus rarely resorted to, due to the inherited hostility towards the doctrine of lex commissoria. Rethinking local laws on preliminary and temporary court orders to match them with such globally known ex parte preliminary measures as the English Mareva Injunction or the French Saisie Conservatoire, which allow creditors to swiftly freeze debtors' assets and thus substitute self-help repossession, has also been given short shrift. The enforcement segment, consequently, remains the Achilles' heel of secured transaction law reforms in civil law systems. This article desires to contribute to reform literature by addressing these deficiencies and by offering tested, fully or partially fitting, functional equivalents of self-help repossession. † The author would like to thank the research assistance of his doctoral candidates Agnes Horvath and Gvantsa Elgendashvili.

Suggested Citation

Tajti (Thaythy), Tibor, The efficient enforcement challenge of secured transactions law reforms in civil law systems-self-help repossession, strict foreclosure, and other methods for the acceleration of enforcement of security interests † (October 03, 2024). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=

Tibor Tajti (Thaythy) (Contact Author)

Central European University-Private University, Vienna, Austria ( email )

Quellenstrasse 51
Vienna, Hungary 1100
Hungary
302440707 (Phone)
2330 (Fax)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
0
Abstract Views
16
PlumX Metrics