48 Pages Posted: 12 Feb 2004
Date Written: February 10, 2004
One of the enduring puzzles of New York City's housing market, is the persistence of the housing cooperative, despite the prevailing wisdom that condominiums are more valuable than cooperatives. In this article, we examine the theoretical advantages and disadvantages of cooperatives and condominiums, and apply these theoretical insights to empirically test whether there is a price premium attributable to condominium housing. We then use our findings to speculate as to why the cooperative form remains dominant in New York City and whether its dominance is likely to continue in the future. The empirical analysis is based on hedonic models of house values and uses rich data on apartments sold in New York City between 1984 and 2002.
In most instances, theory suggests several reasons why the condominium may be a more efficient and desirable housing form than the cooperative. Unlike the case of cooperatives, condominium owners do not share liability on mortgage debt, they are free to transfer their apartments to whomever they choose, they are subject to fewer rules than cooperative apartment owners and, correspondingly, they need spend less time in internal governance. Our empirical findings confirm the theoretical prediction that legal form does indeed matter. With one important exception, condominium apartments are significantly more valuable than comparable cooperative apartments. The one exception suggests that for some owners, the benefits of restriction and exclusivity that the cooperative form offers may be utility-maximizing. Therefore, we speculate that, except for the segment of the market that seeks a socially exclusive residential environment, the continued dominance of cooperative housing in New York City is probably more a function of legal impediments to conversion and transaction costs than the economic advantages offered by the form.
Keywords: Real estate, housing, condominiums, cooperatives
JEL Classification: K11, R00, R31
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Schill, Michael H. and Voicu, Ioan and Miller, Jonathan, The Condominium v. Cooperative Puzzle: An Empirical Analysis of Housing in New York City (February 10, 2004). NYU, Law & Economics Research Paper No. 04-003; NYU, Public Law Research Paper No. 75; and NYU Ctr for Real Estate & Urban Policy Paper No. 2004-1. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=502362 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.502362