Three Strikes and You're Out: Reply to Cooper and Willis
14 Pages Posted: 4 Mar 2004
There are 2 versions of this paper
Three Strikes and You're Out: Reply to Cooper and Willis
Three Strikes and You're Out: Reply to Cooper and Willis
Date Written: March 2004
Abstract
Cooper and Willis (2003) is the latest in a sequence of criticisms of our methodology for estimating aggregate nonlinearities when microeconomic adjustment is lumpy. Their case is based on "reproducing" our main findings using artificial data generated by a model where microeconomic agents face quadratic adjustment costs. That is, they supposedly find our results where they should not be found. The three claims on which they base their case are incorrect. Their mistakes range from misinterpreting their own simulation results to failing to understand the context in which our procedures should be applied. They also claim that our approach assumes that employment decisions depend on the gap between the target and current level of unemployment. This is incorrect as well, since the "gap approach" has been derived formally from at least as sophisticated microeconomic models as the one they present. On a more positive note, the correct interpretation of Cooper and Willis's results shows that our procedures are surprisingly robust to significant departures from the assumptions made in our original derivations.
Keywords: Adjustment hazard, aggregate nonlinearities, lumpy adjustment, observed and unobserved gaps, quadratic adjustment
JEL Classification: E2, J2, J6
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
The Economics of Labor Adjustment: Mind the Gap
By Russell Cooper and Jonathan L. Willis
-
The Economics of Labor Adjustment: Mind the Gap
By Jonathan L. Willis and Russell Cooper
-
Factor Adjustments after Deregulation: Panel Evidence from Colombian Plants
By Marcela Eslava, John Haltiwanger, ...
-
Factor Adjustments after Deregulation: Panel Evidence from Colombian Plants
By Marcela Eslava, John Haltiwanger, ...
-
Protection, Openness and Factor Adjustment: Evidence from the Manufacturing Sector in Uruguay
-
Protection, Openness, and Factor Adjustment: Evidence from the Manufacturing Sector in Uruguay
-
Mind the (Approximation) Gap: A Robustness Analysis
By Russell Cooper and Jonathan L. Willis
-
Microeconomic Flexibility in India and Pakistan: Employment Adjustment at the Firm Level