Professional Insecurity, Accountant Identity and the Erosion of Accountancy's Jurisdictional Boundaries
40 Pages Posted: 10 May 2004
Abstract
This paper examines attitudes about professionalism in accounting shortly before the debacles of Enron and Andersen. Interviews with experienced Canadian Chartered Accountants (CAs) conducted mostly in late 2000 and early 2001 indicate significant doubts about the notion of auditor independence and a relatively high degree of uncertainty about the future of the profession. Accountants also expressed significant difficulties in describing the basic features of what it meant to be a professional accountant. Based on these observations we introduce and detail the construct of professional insecurity. Relying on Giddens' theoretical developments on the role of trust and systems of expertise in today's society, we reflect about the significance and implications of CAs' professional insecurity, particularly in terms of its impact on accountancy's ability to secure its jurisdictional boundaries. Our thesis is that the difficulties that accountants experienced in their day-to-day life in sustaining a coherent sense of self-identity were particularly stressful to them given people's fundamental need for coherence, and significantly affected the capacities of their profession to hold jurisdiction.
Keywords: Accounting profession, Auditor independence, Professional identity, Professional insecurity, Systems of expertise
JEL Classification: M41, M47, M49
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Doing Qualitative Field Research in Management Accounting: Positioning Data to Contribute to Theory
-
The Importance of Circulating and Presenting Manuscripts: Evidence from the Accounting Literature
-
Rethinking the Influence of Agency Theory in the Accounting Academy
By Jeffrey R. Cohen and Lori Holder-webb
-
Constituting the Academic Performer: The Spectre of Superficiality and Stagnation in Academia
By Yves Gendron
-
Professional-Organizational Commitment: A Study of Canadian Professional Accountants
By Yves Gendron, Roy Suddaby, ...
-
By Sven Modell
-
By Henning Zülch, Dominic Detzen, ...