Clear Sailing Agreements: A Special Form of Collusion in Class Action Settlements

27 Pages Posted: 15 Jun 2004  

William D. Henderson

Indiana University Maurer School of Law

Abstract

A clear sailing agreement (or clause) is a compromise in which a class action defendant agrees not to contest the class lawyer's petition for attorneys' fees. This Article argues that clear sailing provisions often facilitate collusive settlements in cases involving non-pecuniary relief or claims-made common funds that return all unclaimed monies to the defendant. Because these types of settlements present difficult valuation problems, trial courts lack a clear benchmark for calculating attorneys' fees. Defendants and class can exploit this uncertainty by presenting an inflated settlement value to the court (to justify higher attorneys' fees) while simultaneously reducing the true cost imposed on the defendant. Although courts purportedly apply "heightened scrutiny" to settlements involving clear sailing agreements, this approach rarely threatens the underlying settlement. As a result, clear sailing agreements tend to undermine the deterrence function of class action by producing settlements that are systemically too low. This Article proposes a per se ban on settlements that rely upon clear sailing provisions. In addition, this Article recommends the appointment of guardian ad litem to litigate the issue of attorneys' fees in all cases involving non-pecuniary relief or a claims-made reverter fund.

Keywords: Class actions, clear sailing agreements, settlements

JEL Classification: K1

Suggested Citation

Henderson, William D., Clear Sailing Agreements: A Special Form of Collusion in Class Action Settlements. Tulane Law Review , Vol. 77, p. 813, 2003. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=556266

William D. Henderson (Contact Author)

Indiana University Maurer School of Law ( email )

211 S. Indiana Avenue
Bloomington, IN 47405
United States
812-856-1788 (Phone)
812-855-0555 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
141
Rank
168,913
Abstract Views
2,848