Political Disobedience in the Idf: The Scope of the Legal Right of Soldiers to Be Excused from Taking Part in Military Activities in the Occupied Territories

Israel Law Review, Vol. 36, pp. 73-110

38 Pages Posted: 6 Sep 2004

See all articles by Barak Medina

Barak Medina

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Faculty of Law

Abstract

At issue is the appropriate legal reaction to so-called selective conscientious objections in the current Israeli context, accounting for both consequential considerations and deontological ones. It is argued that a relevant distinction in this respect is between objections committed by members of a permanent minority, which are based on views that are practically excluded from the political discourse, and objections which are guided by what Rawls calls political principles, that is, the principles of justice which regulate the constitution. This distinction can explain and justify the current policy of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) of granting exemptions to Ultra-Orthodox Jews and to Arabs (even if not all these cases reflect so-called full conscientious objection) while denying an exemption to those who refuse to serve based on their opposition to the IDF's activities in the Occupied Territories. However, it is argued that the important expressive role of such refusals requires a more measured approach, by either legitimizing a limited number of such acts or imposing only minimal sanctions (while formally de-legitimizing such acts). These arguments are preceded by an assessment of an alternative possible justification of legitimizing refusals, to prevent the implementation of unlawful activities by the IDF. It is argued that this purpose does not justify legitimization of refusals except in particular instances that are specified.

Suggested Citation

Medina, Barak, Political Disobedience in the Idf: The Scope of the Legal Right of Soldiers to Be Excused from Taking Part in Military Activities in the Occupied Territories. Israel Law Review, Vol. 36, pp. 73-110, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=586021

Barak Medina (Contact Author)

Hebrew University of Jerusalem - Faculty of Law ( email )

Mount Scopus
Mount Scopus, IL 91905
Israel

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
125
Abstract Views
1,191
rank
269,116
PlumX Metrics