Law, Politics, and Impeachment: The Impeachment of Roh Moo-Hyun from a Comparative Constitutional Perspective
30 Pages Posted: 3 Nov 2005 Last revised: 5 Oct 2007
In March 2004, the National Assembly of South Korea impeached President Roh Moo-hyun and brought about an immediate suspension of Roh's presidency. Two months later, the Constitutional Court of Korea restored the status quo by dismissing the impeachment and reinstating the President. This episode marks the first time in the history of modern constitutionalism that a president impeached by a legislative body has been reinstated by a judicial body. This Article focuses on one slice of this remarkable turn of events: its constitutional dimension from the perspective of comparative constitutional law. After explaining the Constitutional Court's decision, this Article discusses the significance of the ruling for three broad questions of comparative constitutional law: judicial decisionmaking as a distinct form of constitutional interpretation; the dual nature - legal and political - of the impeachment process and the proper role of the courts in it; and historical, political, and institutional factors that lead to the doctrine of judicial supremacy. Comparisons to the U.S. model of presidential impeachment are made throughout the Article.
Keywords: Impeachment, Judicial Review, Constitutional Court of Korea
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Show Me the Money: The Dominance of Wealth in Determining Rights Performance in Asia
The Role of Public Law in a Developing Asia
Article 9 of the Japanese Constitution and the Rule of Law
Article 9 of the Constitution of Japan and the Use of Procedural and Substantive Heuristics for Consensus
By Mark Chinen
Constitutional Reform on Taiwan: Fulfilling a Chinese Notion of Democratic Sovereignty?
By Piero Tozzi
East Asian Foundations for Constitutionalism: Three Models Reconstructed
Constitutionalism and the Search for Legal and Political Legitimacy in the Asian States