Integration of Statistical Methods and Judgment for Time Series Forecasting: Principles from Empirical Research
FORECASTING WITH JUDGMENT, G. Wright and P. Goodwin, eds., John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 269-293, 1998
33 Pages Posted: 22 Jul 2008 Last revised: 22 Jul 2008
Abstract
We consider how judgment and statistical methods should be integrated for time-series forecasting. Our review of published empirical research identified 47 studies, all but four published since 1985. Five procedures were identified: revising judgment; combining forecasts; revising extrapolations; rule-based forecasting; and econometric forecasting. This literature suggests that integration generally improves accuracy when the experts have domain knowledge and when significant trends are involved. Integration is valuable to the extent that judgments are used as inputs to the statistical methods, that they contain additional relevant information, and that the integration scheme is well structured. The choice of an integration approach can have a substantial impact on the accuracy of the resulting forecasts. Integration harms accuracy when judgment is biased or its use is unstructured. Equal-weights combining should be regarded as the benchmark and it is especially appropriate where series have high uncertainty or high instability. When the historical data involve high uncertainty or high instability, we recommend revising judgment, revising extrapolations, or combining. When good domain knowledge is available for the future as well as for the past, we recommend rule-based forecasting or econometric methods.
Keywords: Forecasting, time series forecasting, integration
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
By Fred Collopy and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Error Measures for Generalizing About Forecasting Methods: Empirical Comparisons
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy
-
By J. Scott Armstrong and Robert Carbone
-
Causal Forces: Structuring Knowledge for Time-Series Extrapolation
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy
-
Expert Opinions About Extrapolation and the Mystery of the Overlooked Discontinuities
By Fred Collopy and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Beyond Accuracy: Comparison of Criteria Used to Select Forecasting Methods
By Thomas Yokum and J. Scott Armstrong
-
Structuring Knowledge Retrieval: An Analysis of Decomposed Quantitative Judgments
By Donald G. Macgregor, Sarah Lichtenstein, ...
-
Identification of Asymmetric Prediction Intervals Through Causal Forces
By J. Scott Armstrong and Fred Collopy