Flattening the Organization: The Effect of Organizational Reporting Structure on Budgeting Effectiveness

42 Pages Posted: 8 Jun 2005

See all articles by R. Lynn Hannan

R. Lynn Hannan

Tulane University - A.B. Freeman School of Business

Frederick W. Rankin

Colorado State University, Fort Collins - College of Business

Kristy L. Towry

Emory University

Date Written: April 2006

Abstract

This study investigates whether increasing a superior's span of control reduces the effectiveness of capital budgeting in eliciting truthful reports. We conduct an experiment based on a modification of the capital budgeting setting described by Antle and Eppen (1985). This modification incorporates the notion that the superior's utility for wealth increases at a decreasing rate, as well as the recent empirical evidence that individuals have utility for enforcing social norms. Specifically, we assume the superior is willing to incur a cost in order to punish a subordinate who she believes is incorporating excess slack in his budget, thereby violating a social norm. These theoretical refinements lead to the prediction that as the span of control increases, superiors will be more willing to reject project proposals with high budgeted costs. We further predict that subordinates under an expanded span of control will anticipate the superiors' increased "toughness," and will respond by reducing their budgetary slack. We conduct an experiment to test these predictions. The experimental results are consistent with our theory. That is, as the span of control is increased, superiors show a greater willingness to reject projects for which they believe slack is excessive, and subordinates respond by reducing slack. The net result of these two effects is that as the span of control is increased, superiors earn more profit per subordinate. Thus, our study suggests that increasing the span of control can improve the effectiveness of the budgeting process, which is an important component of most firms' control environments. Although prior research has generally assumed that increasing the span of control weakens the control environment, our study demonstrates that increasing the span of control can actually strengthen it.

JEL Classification: M40, M46, G31, G34, L23

Suggested Citation

Hannan, Rebecca Lynn and Rankin, Frederick W. and Towry, Kristy L., Flattening the Organization: The Effect of Organizational Reporting Structure on Budgeting Effectiveness (April 2006). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=734723 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.734723

Rebecca Lynn Hannan

Tulane University - A.B. Freeman School of Business ( email )

6823 St Charles Ave
New Orleans, LA 70118
United States

Frederick W. Rankin

Colorado State University, Fort Collins - College of Business ( email )

Fort Collins, CO 80523
United States

Kristy L. Towry (Contact Author)

Emory University ( email )

Goizueta Business School
1300 Clifton Road
Atlanta, GA 30322
United States
404-727-4895 (Phone)

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
868
Abstract Views
5,233
rank
29,845
PlumX Metrics