Financing Constraints and Corporate Investment: Response to Kaplan and Zingales
39 Pages Posted: 16 Jun 1998 Last revised: 5 Dec 2022
Date Written: January 1996
Kaplan and Zingales (1995, hereafter KZ) criticize Fazzari, Hubbard and Petersen (1988, hereafter FHP) and much ensuing research that uses cross-sectional differences in firm behavior to test for financing constraints on investment. This reply identifies flaws in the KZ analysis. The questions KZ raise have been considered extensively and rigorously in the literature (most of which is not addressed in KZ), with results broadly similar to those of FHP. We also challenge both of KZ's main results. First, their finding that most of the FHP firms are not financially constrained relies on an inappropriate operational definition of what it means to be constrained. Their definition ignores the incentives for firms that operate in imperfect capital markets to accumulate stocks of cash or maintain unused debt capacity to offset partially shocks to the flow of internal finance. Second, the KZ regression results (lower sensitivity of investment to cash flow for firms classified as constrained than for those classified as unconstrained) are uninformative. Their classification approach relies on possibly self- serving managerial statements that may present a distorted picture of firm's availability of finance. It also employs misleading criteria to make unrealistically fine distinctions in the degree of financing constraints, and emphasizes financial distress rather than financing constraints. Finally, econometric problems affect the interpretation of the KZ regressions. We conclude that the KZ findings do not contradict the interpretation of the empirical results in FHP and subsequent research.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Financing Constraints and Corporate Investment
By Steven M. Fazzari, Bruce C. Petersen, ...
Capital-Market Imperfections and Investment
Measurement Error and the Relationship between Investment and Q
By Timothy Erickson and Toni M. Whited
Inflation, Taxation, and Corporate Investment: A Q-Theory Approach
The Stock Market, Profit and Investment
By Olivier J. Blanchard, Changyong Rhee, ...
Wealth Maximization and the Cost of Capital
Investment-Cash Flow Sensitivities are Not Valid Measures of Financing Constraints
By Steven N. Kaplan and Luigi Zingales
The Present Value of Profits and Cyclical Movements in Investment
The Economic Effects of Dividend Taxation