How Useful is the Return on Capital Employed (Roce) as a Performance Indicator?

AJMS, Vol. 1, 4th Quarter, 2005

16 Pages Posted: 6 Jul 2005

See all articles by Enyi Patrick Enyi

Enyi Patrick Enyi

Babcock University - School of Management Sciences

Abstract

The use of the Return On Capital Employed (ROCE) as a performance indicator is questioned in this paper. The paper is using the premise that performance indication can only be meaningful to the user if it bears a true reflection of the relationship that it intends to measure. An empirical evaluation of financial statements of 16 firms listed on the Nigerian Stock Exchange reveal that ROCE as currently defined presents distorted and misleading financial ratio which bears no relationship with the actual capital usage of a firm. It also revealed that a true measure of efficiency in the use of capital resources cannot be done using capital employed as defined in a company's balance sheet. This is because the balance sheet capital is a static measure of capital employed at a date and not for the entire period. Hence, the result to be obtained from such measurement would invariably be influenced by the static nature of the value of capital employed as at that date. A more refined approach considered the firm's actual capital turnover (usage) ratio and presents an Enhanced Return On Capital Employed (EROCE) ratio measurement that correlates better with a firm's capital employed using the Spearman's correlation coefficient formula. The study recommends the replacement of the ROCE with EROCE for maximum effectiveness.

Keywords: Return On Capital Employed, Enhanced Return On Capital Employed, ROCE, EROCE, Market Value Analysis, MVA, Capital Turnover Ratio, CTR, Accounting Ratios, Capital Employed, Net Profit, Capital Turnover Rate

JEL Classification: M41, D42, E22, G14, G32

Suggested Citation

Enyi, Enyi Patrick, How Useful is the Return on Capital Employed (Roce) as a Performance Indicator?. AJMS, Vol. 1, 4th Quarter, 2005. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=753124

Enyi Patrick Enyi (Contact Author)

Babcock University - School of Management Sciences ( email )

Babcock University
Sagamu-Benin Expressway
Ilishan-Remo, Ogun 121103
Nigeria
8069619343 (Phone)
8069619343 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.babcockuni.edu.ng

Here is the Coronavirus
related research on SSRN

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,626
Abstract Views
8,068
rank
10,883
PlumX Metrics