The Article 2 Merchant Rules: Karl Llewellyn's Attempt to Achieve the Good, the True, the Beautiful in Commercial Law

45 Pages Posted: 11 Aug 2005  

Ingrid Michelsen Hillinger

Boston College Law School

Abstract

In 1949, the Uniform Commercial Code was unveiled by Karl Llewellyn and his drafting-crew, which legally distinguished merchants and nonmerchants within Article 2 of the Code. However, the author suggests that a merchant muddle has arisen due to a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature and purpose of Article 2, which the author argues was never intended to codify merchant custom and trade usage. Section I of the article describes and then refutes the perception that the merchant rules codify actual business practices. It goes on to discuss some of the actual considerations that prompted the substantive content of the merchant rules. Section II explains how the merchant/nonmerchant bifurcation naturally resulted from Llewellyn's jurisprudence. Section III explores the problem of deciding who is a merchant and why it should matter, using as an example the question of whether a farmer is a merchant under the statute of frauds. Finally, section IV discusses the legacy of Llewellyn's Article 2 merchant theory and concludes that a thorough reevaluation of the merchant rules is now in order.

Keywords: Uniform Commercial Code, Article 2, sales article, sales law, merchants, nonmerchants, merchant definition, merchant provisions, codified merchant customs, trade customs, judicial determination of relevance, pragmatism, business practices, merchant rules, Karl Llewellyn, merchant theory

Suggested Citation

Michelsen Hillinger, Ingrid, The Article 2 Merchant Rules: Karl Llewellyn's Attempt to Achieve the Good, the True, the Beautiful in Commercial Law. Georgetown Law Journal, Vol. 73, pp. 1141-1184, 1985; Boston College Law School Research Paper No. 1985-01. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=781044

Ingrid Michelsen Hillinger (Contact Author)

Boston College Law School ( email )

885 Centre Street
Newton, MA 02459-1163
United States

Paper statistics

Downloads
181
Rank
135,875
Abstract Views
2,780