Fear of Democracy: A Cultural Evaluation of Sunstein on Risk
52 Pages Posted: 12 Sep 2005
Abstract
What dynamics shape public risk perceptions? What significance should such perceptions have in the formation of risk regulation? In Laws of Fear: Beyond the Precautionary Principle (2005), Cass Sunstein catalogs a variety of cognitive and social mechanisms that he argues inflate public estimations of various societal risks. To counter the impact of irrational public fears, he advocates delegation of authority to politically insulated experts using economic cost-benefit analysis. Missing from Sunstein's impressive account, however, is any attention to the impact of cultural cognition, the tendency of individuals to form risk perceptions that reflect and reinforce their cultural worldviews. Relying on existing and original empirical research, we use this dynamic to develop an alternative cultural evaluator model, which better explains individual variation in risk perception, differences of opinions among experts, and the intensity of political conflict over risk than does Sunstein's irrational weigher model. Cultural cognition also complicates Sunstein's policy prescriptions. Because the public fears that Sunstein describes as irrational express cultural values, expert cost-benefit analysis does not merely insulate the law from factual error, as Sunstein argues; rather, it systematically detaches law from popular understandings of the ideal society. Indeed, the best defense of Sunstein's program might be just that: by eliding the role that risk regulation plays in endorsing contested cultural visions, expert cost-benefit analysis protects the law from a divisive and deeply illiberal form of expressive politics. The difficult task for those who understand the phenomenon of cultural cognition and who favor democratic modes of policymaking is to devise procedures that assure that popularly responsive risk regulation is both rational and respectful of diverse cultural worldviews.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Cultural Cognition and Public Policy
By Dan M. Kahan and Donald Braman
-
Culture and Identity-Protective Cognition: Explaining the White Male Effect in Risk Perception
By Dan M. Kahan, Donald Braman, ...
-
Cultural Cognition of the Risks and Benefits of Nanotechnology
By Dan M. Kahan, Donald Braman, ...
-
More Statistics, Less Persuasion: A Cultural Theory of Gun-Risk Perceptions
By Donald Braman and Dan M. Kahan
-
Culture and Environment in the Pacific Northwest
By Richard Ellis and Fred Thompson
-
Cultural Cognition and Public Policy: The Case of Outpatient Commitment Laws
By Dan M. Kahan, Donald Braman, ...
-
Cultural Cognition of Scientific Consensus
By Dan M. Kahan, Hank Jenkins-smith, ...
-
Fixing the Communications Failure
By Dan M. Kahan
-
By Dan M. Kahan, Donald Braman, ...