Download this Paper Open PDF in Browser

When are we Rightfully Aggrieved?: A Comment on Postema

15 Pages Posted: 22 Sep 2005  

Larry Alexander

University of San Diego School of Law

Abstract

Gerald Postema argues that Joel Feinberg's harm and offense principles in The Moral Limits of the Criminal Law point toward, but are not co-extensive with, what Postema labels "grievance legal moralism." Grievance legal moralism is a liberal view that posits, as the proper concern of the criminal law, not that a moral wrong has been committed, but that a moral wrong has been committed about which someone has a legitimate grievance. As Postema says, "perhaps it is just and right that Pol Pot suffer for his sins, but it is not right for you or me to exact that suffering, to exact that justice."

In my response to Postema, I raise questions about grievance legal moralism from many angles, including its internal coherence as well as its normative attractiveness, and I conclude that it is of dubious plausibility as a principle for limiting the reach of the criminal law. I also question whether the distinction between criminal law and other methods of handling non-grievance immoralities makes normative sense. Finally, I raise doubts about Postema's ability to meet the challenges of Parfit's "malicious conception" case and Kristol's gladiatorial contest case by claiming, as Postema does, that both involve wrongs that are grievances of the child conceived and the gladiator killed.

Keywords: paternalism, legal moralism, offense, harm principle, limits of the criminal law

JEL Classification: K10

Suggested Citation

Alexander, Larry, When are we Rightfully Aggrieved?: A Comment on Postema. Legal Theory, Vol. 11, 2005; San Diego Legal Studies Paper No. 07-02. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=802785

Lawrence Alexander (Contact Author)

University of San Diego School of Law ( email )

5998 Alcala Park
San Diego, CA 92110-2492
United States
619-260-2317 (Phone)
619-260-4728 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
116
Rank
202,031
Abstract Views
1,165