Toward the Framers' Understanding of Advice and Consent: An Historical and Textual Inquiry

38 Pages Posted: 29 Sep 2005

See all articles by Adam White

Adam White

George Mason University - Antonin Scalia Law School; American Enterprise Institute

Abstract

Some proponents of current judicial nominees, including President Bush himself, suggest that the Senate is obligated to act on judicial nominations, either confirming them or explicitly rejecting them. In this essay, I consider whether the Framers would agree with such an assertion (leaving aside the question of whether the Framers' understanding of "advice and consent" comports with the objective "original meaning" of "advice and consent"). My analysis focuses primarily on two long-overlooked pieces of evidence: First, I consider the actual practice of "advice and consent" in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (the example cited by Nathaniel Gorham, the original proponent of "advice and consent," at the Constitutional Convention), by examining Massachusetts state records from the 1780s. Second, I look for insight into "advice and consent" by considering James Madison's failed alternative proposal, the discretionary Senate majority veto. Both of these inquiries suggest the same conclusion: "Advice and consent," as likely understood by the Framers, did not include an implicit Senate obligation to act on judicial nominations.

Keywords: Advice, consent, framers, judicial, nominations, senate, judiciary, Hamilton, Madison, constitution, textualism, originalism, history

JEL Classification: K19

Suggested Citation

White, Adam, Toward the Framers' Understanding of Advice and Consent: An Historical and Textual Inquiry. Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy, Vol. 29, No. 1, Fall 2005. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=813464

Adam White (Contact Author)

George Mason University - Antonin Scalia Law School ( email )

3301 Fairfax Drive
Arlington, VA 22201
United States

HOME PAGE: http://https://www.law.gmu.edu/faculty/directory/fulltime/white_adam

American Enterprise Institute ( email )

1150 17th Street, N.W.
Washington, DC 20036
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
210
Abstract Views
1,567
rank
148,189
PlumX Metrics