Mental Capacity as Metaphor

40 Pages Posted: 7 Dec 2005  

Carl S. Bjerre

University of Oregon School of Law

Abstract

Despite its foundational role in contract law, the term mental capacity is entirely metaphorical, and a detailed analysis of three representative judicial opinions shows that courts' explanations of the term are equally metaphorical. As such, the term mental capacity nicely illustrates the cognitivist view that abstract concepts arise through an imaginative but orderly projection from the domain of bodily and social experience. Legal Realists, including notably Felix Cohen, condemned metaphors for their supposed failure to constrain judges, but this article and other recent empirical work indicates that metaphorical thinking is indeed constrained. I accordingly suggest that thinkers such as Cohen would probably have welcomed the cognitive analysis of metaphor in law, both for its methods and for its substantively progressive disposition.

Keywords: capacity, mental capacity, metaphor, cognitive, cognitivism, realism, Cohen

Suggested Citation

Bjerre, Carl S., Mental Capacity as Metaphor. International Journal for the Semiotics of Law, Vol. 18, pp. 101-140, 2005. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=863025

Carl S. Bjerre (Contact Author)

University of Oregon School of Law ( email )

1515 Agate Street
Eugene, OR Oregon 97403
United States
541-346-3981 (Phone)
541-346-1564 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
111
Rank
204,537
Abstract Views
1,006