Comparing Sharpe Ratios: So Where are the P-Values?

Journal of Asset Management, Vol. 8, No. 5, pp. 308-336

30 Pages Posted: 3 Mar 2006 Last revised: 19 Mar 2008

J.D. Opdyke

DataMineit, LLC; GE Capital

Abstract

Until recently, since Jobson & Korkie (1981) derivations of the asymptotic distribution of the Sharpe ratio that are practically useable for generating confidence intervals or for conducting one- and two-sample hypothesis tests have relied on the restrictive, and now widely refuted, assumption of normally distributed returns. This paper presents an easily implemented formula for the asymptotic distribution that is valid under very general conditions - stationary and ergodic returns - thus permitting time-varying conditional volatilities, serial correlation, and other non-iid returns behavior. It is consistent with that of Christie (2005), but it is more mathematically tractable and intuitive, and simple enough to be used in a spreadsheet. Also generalized beyond the normality assumption is the small sample bias adjustment presented in Christie (2005). A thorough simulation study examines the finite sample behavior of the derived one- and two-sample estimators under the realistic returns conditions of concurrent leptokurtosis, asymmetry, and importantly (for the two-sample estimator), strong positive correlation between funds, the effects of which have been overlooked in previous studies. The two-sample statistic exhibits reasonable level control and good power under these real world conditions. This makes its application to the ubiquitous Sharpe ratio rankings of mutual funds and hedge funds very useful, since the implicit pairwise comparisons in these orderings have little inferential value on their own. Using actual returns data from twenty mutual funds, the statistic yields statistically significant results for many such pairwise comparisons of the ranked funds. It should be useful for other purposes as well, wherever Sharpe ratios are used in performance assessment.

Keywords: performance, risk, portfolio, mutual fund, hedge fund, asymmetry, heavy tails

JEL Classification: C10, C12, C13, G10, G11

Suggested Citation

Opdyke, J.D., Comparing Sharpe Ratios: So Where are the P-Values?. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=886728

J.D. Opdyke (Contact Author)

DataMineit, LLC; GE Capital ( email )

FL
United States
617-943-6463 (Phone)
781-639-6463 (Fax)

HOME PAGE: http://www.DataMineIt.com/index.htm

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,198
Rank
12,859
Abstract Views
4,232