Claiming a Large Slice of a Small Pie: Asymmetric Disconfirmation in Negotiation
69 Pages Posted: 10 Mar 2006
Date Written: December 2005
Abstract
Three studies show that negotiators consistently underestimate the size of the bargaining zone in distributive negotiations (the small pie bias) and, by implication, overestimate the share of the surplus they claim (the large slice bias). We explain the results by asymmetric disconfirmation: Negotiators with initial estimates of their counterpart's reservation price that are "inside" the bargaining zone tend to behave consistently with these estimates, which become self-fulfilling, whereas negotiators with initial "outside" estimates revise their perceptions in the face of strong disconfirming evidence. Asymmetric disconfirmation can produce a population-level bias even when initial perceptions are accurate on average. We suggest that asymmetric disconfirmation has implications for confirmation bias and self-fulfilling prophecy research in social perception.
Keywords: confirmation bias, feedback, learning, negotiation, self-fulfilling prophecy, triangle hypothesis
JEL Classification: C70, C78, D74, D83
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
Disconnecting Outcomes and Evaluations: The Role of Negotiator Reference Points
By Adam D. Galinsky, Thomas Mussweiler, ...
-
When Better is Worse: Envy and the Use of Deception in Negotiations
-
How to Attract Customers by Giving Them the Short End of the Stick
By Alison King Lo, John G. Lynch, ...
-
Friendship, Deception and Punishment in Negotiations
By Per Van Der Wijst and Emiel Krahmer
-
Best Foot Forward or Waiting Game: First Mover Effects in a Distributive Negotiation
By John M. Oesch and Glen Whyte
-
Taking Stereotypes Out of Stereotype Threat: The Effect of Role-Based Expectations
By Adam D. Galinsky, Leigh Thompson, ...
-
Do You a Favor? Social Implications of High Aspirations in Negotiation
By Hannah Riley Bowles, Linda Babcock, ...
-
By Adam D. Galinsky, Geoffrey J. Leonardelli, ...