The Poverty of the Moral Stimulus

MORAL PSYCHOLOGY, THE EVOLUTION OF MORALITY, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ed., Vol. 1, MIT Press, Forthcoming

Georgetown Public Law Research Paper No. 896388

12 Pages Posted: 19 Apr 2006  

John Mikhail

Georgetown University Law Center

Abstract

One of the most influential arguments in contemporary philosophy and cognitive science is Chomsky's argument from the poverty of the stimulus. In this response to an essay by Chandra Sripada, I defend an analogous argument from the poverty of the moral stimulus. I argue that Sripada's criticism of moral nativism appears to rest on the mistaken assumption that the learning target in moral cognition consists of a series of simple imperatives, such as "share your toys" or "don't hit other children." In fact, the available evidence suggests that the moral competence of adults and even young children is considerably more complex and exhibits many characteristics of a well-developed legal code, including abstract theories of crime, tort, contract, and agency. Since the emergence of this knowledge cannot be explained by appeals to explicit instruction, or to any known processes of imitation, internalization, socialization and the like, there are grounds for concluding it may be innate. Simply put, to explain the development of intuitive jurisprudence in each individual, we must attribute unconscious knowledge and complex mental operations to her that go well beyond anything she has been taught.

Keywords: moral cognition, moral intuition, moral grammar, universal grammar, nativism, innate, jurisprudence, crime, tort, contract, agency, human rights, Locke, Hume, Rawls, Chomsky, Fodor

JEL Classification: D63, D64, K00, K13, K14

Suggested Citation

Mikhail, John, The Poverty of the Moral Stimulus. MORAL PSYCHOLOGY, THE EVOLUTION OF MORALITY, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, ed., Vol. 1, MIT Press, Forthcoming; Georgetown Public Law Research Paper No. 896388. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=896388

John Mikhail (Contact Author)

Georgetown University Law Center ( email )

600 New Jersey Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20001
United States
202-662-9392 (Phone)
202-662-9409 (Fax)

Paper statistics

Downloads
1,128
Rank
14,006
Abstract Views
5,581