Working Through 'Bitter Experiences' Towards Constitutionalisation. A Critique of the Disregard for History in European Constitutional Theory: Are Those that Forget the Past Doomed to Repeat its Mistakes? A Comment on Christian Joerges

European University Institute Law Working Paper No. 2005/14

32 Pages Posted: 15 Jun 2006

See all articles by Christian Joerges

Christian Joerges

University of Bremen - Faculty of Law; Hertie School of Governance

Dario Castiglione

University of Exeter - Department of Politics

Date Written: December 2005

Abstract

The defeat European constitutionalism has experienced in the French and the Dutch referendum has many reasons. The deficiency this contribution addresses is the lack sensitivity for the historical dimensions of the integration project in general and the darker legacies of law in particular. Three exploratory steps are undertaken: (1) The first deals with the diversity of European pasts. It is submitted that European constitutionalism must respect this diversity and promote toleration rather than homogeneity. (2) The second discusses the presence of European pasts in two fields. One is the controversy over "social Europe" which is traced back to divergent national histories, memories and anxieties. The other concerns the search for a European identity and citizenship. (3) The reluctance of Europeans to confront the darker side of their pasts, including the failures and fragility of law and legal institutions, has many good and bad reasons. We risk getting involved in a bitter politicisation of our memories. The contest over memories seems, however, not only unavoidable; it might become a constructive exercise. The search for a new future in post war Europe was a response to the atrocities of the Nazi period. That legacy is still alive and can be revitalized. The readiness to face Europe's past can be understood as a European vocation which may provide the integration project with an unheard of specific legitimacy. In his comment Dario Castiglione discusses Christian Joerges's ideas of deliberative supranationalism and of the 'conflict of disciplines'; and suggests that his analysis of the relevance of the past can be extended by distinguishing between three different modes in which the past can be used: as present in the modern predicament; as a form of public discourse; and as a way of shaping and confronting one's own identity.

Keywords: constitution building, European identity, legitimacy , Nation-state, supranationalism, European citizenship, supremacy, social policy, European Convention

Suggested Citation

Joerges, Christian and Castiglione, Dario, Working Through 'Bitter Experiences' Towards Constitutionalisation. A Critique of the Disregard for History in European Constitutional Theory: Are Those that Forget the Past Doomed to Repeat its Mistakes? A Comment on Christian Joerges (December 2005). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=908829 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.908829

Christian Joerges (Contact Author)

University of Bremen - Faculty of Law ( email )

PO Box 330440
Bremen, 28334
Germany

Hertie School of Governance ( email )

Friedrichstra├če 180
Berlin, 10117
Germany

Dario Castiglione

University of Exeter - Department of Politics ( email )

Amory Building
Rennes Drive
Exeter, EX4 4RJ
United Kingdom

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
124
Abstract Views
840
rank
231,063
PlumX Metrics