Samuel a. Thumma & Jeffrey L. Kirchmeier, Appendix B: United States Supreme Court Justices Citing Dictionaries, from the Lexicon Has Become a Fortress: The United States Supreme Court's Use of Dictionaries

73 Pages Posted: 27 Jul 2006

Abstract

This appendix to The Lexicon Has Become a Fortress: The United States Supreme Court's Use of Dictionaries lists all United States Supreme Court Justices through the 1997-98 Term and every opinion where each Justice cited a dictionary. This appendix also lists the rate at which each Justice used dictionaries per year.

The Article itself, available as a separate download, examines the use of dictionaries by the United States Supreme Court. Beginning with a short history of dictionaries and their use, the Article reviews the Supreme Court Justices' use of dictionaries in their opinions throughout the history of the Court. The Article is critical of the Justices' lack of consistency in their use of dictionaries, and it discusses problems with the use of general purpose dictionaries in legal opinions. In conclusion, the Article makes several suggestions regarding how dictionaries still may be used as an important aid in legal analysis.

Other appendices to this Article are available as separate downloads. The appendices list (1) every term ever defined by a dictionary in a Supreme Court opinion; (2) every case where a Supreme Court Justice has used a dictionary in an opinion; and (3) every dictionary used by a Supreme Court Justice.

An update to this appendix, also available for download, is included in Samuel Thumma and Jeffrey L. Kirchmeier, The Lexicon Remains a Fortress: An Update, 5 The Green Bag 51 (2001).

Keywords: dictionary, dictionaries, supreme court, lexicon

JEL Classification: K10, K40, K00

Suggested Citation

Thumma, Samuel and Kirchmeier, Jeffrey L., Samuel a. Thumma & Jeffrey L. Kirchmeier, Appendix B: United States Supreme Court Justices Citing Dictionaries, from the Lexicon Has Become a Fortress: The United States Supreme Court's Use of Dictionaries. Buffalo Law Review, Vol. 47, p. 397, 1999. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=920515

Samuel Thumma

Perkins Coie ( email )

2901 N. Central Avenue
Suite 2000
Phoenix, AZ 85012-2788
United States

Jeffrey L. Kirchmeier (Contact Author)

CUNY School of Law ( email )

2 Court Square
Long Island City, NY 11101
United States

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
55
Abstract Views
919
rank
365,740
PlumX Metrics