References (68)



The Attitudinal Model, Political Science, Ecological Fallacy and Exaggeration

Dr. Sean Wilson, Esq.

Wright State University

August 3, 2006

Empirical scholars of the United States Supreme Court, Jeffrey Segal and Harold Spaeth, have long contended that Supreme Court decisions are based primarily upon the ideological beliefs of the justices, and that ideology alone accounts for the bulk of choices made in civil liberties cases. However, this conclusion results from the misinterpretation of an ecological regression model. The researchers never modeled the votes of the justices; they only analyzed an index of grouped aggregates. When announcing conclusions, however, scholars equated variation in a voting index with the frequency distribution of binary observations that comprised it. As a result, model conclusions were exaggerated and disciplinary misinformation was created. This work exposes and corrects this problem by re-estimating the relationship between justice ideology and votes with a multilevel approach that uses a logistic regression to directly examine the dependent variable prior to its manipulation into grouped data. The findings demonstrate that ideology models lose about two-thirds of the level of explanation researchers previously proclaimed. This new understanding supports a more limited critique of the role that ideology plays on the Court - one that has a long history in political science that predates the more value-dominant "attitudinal" framework.

Number of Pages in PDF File: 33

Keywords: Attitudinal Model, Segal and Spaeth, Political Science, Ecological Regression, Bivariate Ideology Model, Ecological Fallacy, Exaggeration

Open PDF in Browser Download This Paper

Date posted: August 8, 2006  

Suggested Citation

Wilson, Esq., Dr. Sean, The Attitudinal Model, Political Science, Ecological Fallacy and Exaggeration (August 3, 2006). Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=922183 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.922183

Contact Information

Dr. Sean Wilson, Esq. (Contact Author)
Wright State University ( email )
Department of Political Science
306 Millett Hall
Dayton, OH
United States
937-775-4222 (Phone)
HOME PAGE: http://seanwilson.org
Feedback to SSRN

Paper statistics
Abstract Views: 2,266
Downloads: 315
Download Rank: 74,630
References:  68