Uncovering Identity

28 Pages Posted: 28 Aug 2006

See all articles by Paul Horwitz

Paul Horwitz

University of Alabama School of Law

Abstract

Kenji Yoshino's book, "Covering: The Hidden Assault on Our Civil Rights," offers an instructive and intimate look at the many claims that society makes upon the self. In discussing covering - the demand that one tone down a disfavored identity to fit into the mainstream - it promises to open a productive debate about the shape and future of civil rights law. Its argument that we should move away from an equality-based approach to civil rights law, and toward a liberty-based approach, is especially interesting. Nevertheless, it builds on a shaky foundation.

This book review focuses on Yoshino's treatment of identity, authenticity, and the self in "Covering." Yoshino describes the book as a defense of the True Self against demands for conformity and/or identity performance. He writes that we are all engaged in an act of self-elaboration, a search for authenticity that is the most important work we can do. I make three basic points about Yoshino's placement of authenticity and the True Self at the heart of his project.

First, drawing primarily on the work of Charles Taylor, I argue that it is not clear that the search for authenticity is the most important work we can do as human beings. But even it were, such a project cannot depend only on acts of self-elaboration. Our truest, most authentic selves are often those we forge in moments of dialogue and interaction with others. Second, Yoshino's focus on covering as an act of coerced assimilation fails to fully capture the extent to which one's identity, and one's uses of identity, may be fluid and intentional. Third, I argue that another essential identity trait is present throughout Yoshino's book, but is not adequately acknowledged and examined: class.

My criticisms of Yoshino's foundational treatment of authenticity and the self have three broader implications for his project. First, I suggest that generalizing from the formation of gay identity to other forms of identity may be trickier than the book suggests. Second, I call into question Yoshino's attempt to refigure civil rights as a matter of liberty rather than equality. Third, and more generally, I argue that before we can hold the reason-forcing conversations that Yoshino recommends, we need to reach a firmer understanding of the self, its connection to the broader social world, and the occasions on which we are willing to call certain identity demands reasonable or unreasonable.

Keywords: covering, yoshino, authenticity, self, true self, winnicott, civil rights, identity, antidiscrimination, identity performance, gay rights, equality

JEL Classification: J70

Suggested Citation

Horwitz, Paul, Uncovering Identity. Michigan Law Review, May 2007, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=926574

Paul Horwitz (Contact Author)

University of Alabama School of Law ( email )

P.O. Box 870382
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487
United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
132
Abstract Views
1,463
Rank
33,853
PlumX Metrics