People Accounting: Social Category-Based Choice
Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, Forthcoming
26 Pages Posted: 1 Sep 2006
Abstract
This paper presents people accounting - a hypothesis that describes how a simple numerical imbalance in representation along nominal social category lines can affect people's choice of candidates in highly competitive situations (e.g., awards, jobs, etc.). For example, two scholarship finalists from California and New York may be equally qualified, but the award-winning chance for the California candidate will drop precipitously if 8 of the past 10 winners were from California. Studies 1-3 illustrate this effect. Study 4 reveals people accounting is linked to intergroup fairness concerns and is more likely to occur when the category line is meaningful (e.g., Stanford/Princeton) than when it is not (e.g., left/right-handedness). Study 5 shows that candidates from overrepresented categories (e.g., "Californians") must achieve higher minimum standards in order to be selected. The implication is that highly competitive decisions are often influenced by headcounts along mundane social category lines.
Keywords: Social Categories, Decision Making, Allocations, Fairness, Affirmative Action, Competition
JEL Classification: D6, J1, J5, J7, C7
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Profit Maximization Versus Disadvantageous Inequality: The Impact of Self-Categorization
By Stephen M. Garcia, Avishalom Tor, ...
-
Ranks and Rivals: A Theory of Competition
By Stephen M. Garcia, Avishalom Tor, ...
-
Rankings, Standards, and Competition: Task vs. Scale Comparisons
By Stephen M. Garcia and Avishalom Tor
-
By Kelly E. See
-
The N-Effect: More Competitors, Less Competition
By Stephen M. Garcia and Avishalom Tor
-
The N-Effect: More Competitors, Less Competition
By Stephen M. Garcia and Avishalom Tor
-
Social Categories and Group Preference Disputes: The Aversion to Winner-Take-All Solutions
By Stephen M. Garcia and Dale T. Miller
-
By Steven Salterio and Patrick Legresley
-
Relative Deprivation and Intergroup Competition
By Nir Halevy, Eileen Y. Chou, ...
-
The Price of Equality: Suboptimal Resource Allocations Across Social Categories
By Stephen M. Garcia, Max H. Bazerman, ...