34 Pages Posted: 21 Dec 2006
Insurers play a critical role in the civil justice system. By providing liability insurance to parties who would otherwise be untenable as defendants, insurers make litigation possible. Once litigation materializes, insurers provide representation, pay legal fees, and often play a central role in resolving disputes through settlement or adjudication. In this paper, we explore empirically how these key litigation players make important decisions in the litigation process, like evaluating a case, deciding whether to settle, and if so, on what terms. We find that insurers, though not entirely immune to the effects of cognitive illusions that have been shown to distort litigation decision making, appear to make decisions in a more economically rational fashion than other litigation players. This finding, though preliminary, casts new light on litigation theory and practice.
Keywords: litigation, settlement, heuristics and biases, experts, insurance, anchoring, framing, self-serving bias
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Guthrie, Chris and Rachlinski , Jeffrey J., Insurers, Illusions of Judgment & Litigation. Vanderbilt Law Review, Forthcoming; Vanderbilt Law and Economics Research Paper No. 06-28. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=952493