Sending the Bureaucracy to War
David T. Zaring
University of Pennsylvania - Legal Studies Department
Elena A. Baylis
University of Pittsburgh - School of Law
Iowa Law Review, Vol. 92, 2007
Washington & Lee Legal Studies Paper No. 2007-5
Administrative law has been transformed after 9/11, much to its detriment. Since then, the government has mobilized almost every part of the civil bureaucracy to fight terrorism, including agencies that have no obvious expertise in that task. The vast majority of these bureaucratic initiatives suffer from predictable, persistent, and probably intractable problems - problems that contemporary legal scholars tend to ignore, even though they are central to the work of the writers who created and framed the discipline of administrative law.
We analyze these problems through a survey of four administrative initiatives that exemplify the project of sending bureaucrats to war. The initiatives - two involving terrorism financing, one involving driver licensing, and one involving the adjudication of asylum claims - grow out of the two statutes perhaps most associated with the war on terrorism, the USA PATRIOT Act of 2001 and the REAL ID Act of 2005. In each of our case studies, the civil administrative schemes used to fight terrorism suffer from the incongruity of fitting civil rules into an anti-civil project, the difficulties of delegating wide discretion without adequate supervision, and the problem of using inexpert civil regulators to serve complex law enforcement ends. We conclude that anti-terrorism should rarely be the principal justification for a new administrative initiative, but offer some recommendations as to when it might make sense to re-purpose civil officials as anti-terrorism fighters.
Number of Pages in PDF File: 70
Keywords: national security, terrorism, war on terror, administrative law, administrative agencies, USA PATRIOT Act, REAL ID Act, sanctions, banking, IEEPA, OFAC, Treasury, Homeland Security, immigration, asylum, DMV, drivers license, FinCEN, money laundering
JEL Classification: G28, H11, H56, H77
Date posted: January 10, 2007