Grandfathering and Environmental Regulation: The Law and Economics of New Source Review
Northwestern University Law Review, Vol. 102, 2007
Tulane Public Law Research Paper No. 07-01
55 Pages Posted: 28 Feb 2007
Abstract
The grandfathering of existing sources of pollution is a common feature of the regulatory state. Sources in operation at the time of the enactment of new regulatory requirements are typically exempted from these requirements because of the high cost of retrofitting their operations. Grandfathering regimes give existing sources a significant advantage relative to new sources and therefore give them an incentive to stay in operation longer than they would in the absence of environmental regulation. This effect is further magnified if the existing sources are allowed to modernize without having to meet the standards applicable to new sources.
Over a period spanning more than three decades, from 1970 to 2002, the Environmental Protection Agency crafted a policy for distinguishing between types of plant changes that trigger the application of the new source standards from those that do not. Beginning in 2002, the Bush Administration significantly expanded the scope of permissible grandfathering.
This Article challenges the Bush Administration's view that its policy is environmentally beneficial. While the policy does encourage some desirable modernization that would otherwise not take place, as the Administration contends, it discourages desirable modernization that would otherwise take place. The Administration also ignores the perverse interactions between this policy and other regulatory provisions of the Clean Air Act.
More generally the Article analyzes the contours of desirable grandfathering policies. It shows why policies that are not limited in significant ways give rise to undesirable incentives and are not justifiable on fairness grounds.
Keywords: Environmental law, New source review, Grandfathering, Nonconforming uses
JEL Classification: K23, K32
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
A Two-Dimensional Framework for Analyzing Property Rights Regimes
By Shi-ling Hsu
-
The Tragedy of the Commons and the Myth of a Private Property Solution
By Amy Sinden
-
The Evolution of Private and Open Access Property
By Abraham Bell and Gideon Parchomovsky