Welfare, Resources, and Luck-Egalitarianism
European University Institute Law Working Paper No. 2007/05
28 Pages Posted: 8 Mar 2007
Date Written: February 2007
Abstract
The leading discourse about luck egalitarianism has been informed by the distinction between equality of welfare and equality of resources. This paper attempts to illuminate its significance by focusing on the status of individual preferences (in particular, preferences which are particularly costly to satisfy) as regards egalitarian distribution. It then considers another distinction: that between "persons" and "circumstances" to see how it correlates with the central moral intuition which triggers the egalitarian approach, namely that social inequalities should be allowed to reflect the choices people make in the course of their lives. I argue that if we consistently maintain the centrality of choice for the whole theory, and construct the technical concept of "resources" accordingly, we may well realize that the gap between "equality of welfare" and "equality of resources" is not as wide as many theorists of luck egalitarianism would have us believe. Finally, I address head-on the crucial issue lying in the background of this whole discussion: is the aspiration to eliminate systemically the impact of bad luck egalitarian? Against many critics of luck-egalitarianism, I claim that it is, but only contingently rather than inherently and necessarily.
Keywords: equality, non-discrimination, social justice
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have negative results from your research you’d like to share?
Recommended Papers
-
Gay Rights in the EU: A Long Way Forward for the Union of 27
-
Citizenship as Inherited Property
By Ayelet Shachar and Ran Hirschl
-
Constitutional Disagreement in Europe and the Search for Pluralism
-
The Case of Laval in the Context of the Post-Enlargement EC Law Development
-
Europeanisation of Citizenship within the EU: Perspectives and Ambiguities
-
Proportionality and the Culture of Justification
By Moshe Cohen-eliya and Iddo Porat
-
Citizenship without Respect: The EU's Troubled Equality Ideal