Revisiting the Rational Choice and Rationality Debate in the Social Sciences: Is Theory Possible Without Rationality?

International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 6, pp. 27-38

16 Pages Posted: 25 May 2007

See all articles by A.B. C. Adi

A.B. C. Adi

Lagos Business School; University of Tsukuba

Kenneth Amaeshi

University of Edinburgh Business School; Cranfield University - School of Management

Paul Nnodim

Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts

Abstract

Not only from outside economics, scathing criticisms of the rational choice and rationality assumptions on which much of the economists' models are based have also come from within economics and have constituted a major source of disagreement among economists. Especially, the Austrian school of economics and philosophy distinguishes itself from mainstream economics on this basis. Various theories such as critical realism, holism, Marxism, historicism, functionalism, semiotics, or the praxeology of the Austrian school, have appeared to be alternatives to rational choice and a heated debate have waged on which should be seen as representing a more realistic paradigm of the study of acting human subjects, interacting with others and their environment. The aversion to rational choice stems from its alleged orientation to subjective rationality, instrumental rationality, mechanistic, logical and mathematical formalism, utility maximization etc. Pushed to extreme, rational choice posits a distorted picture of reality that is both mechanistic and destructive. But the same accusations could well be levied against each of the theories that seek to replace rational choice. This paper takes the radical position that the alleged distinctions between rational choice and its rival theories are more imagined than real. Using a metaphysical hermeneutic deconstruction of the conceptualization of "theoria", this paper shows that the modern theory ("theoria") of knowledge takes as its foundational axiom, the agency of the subjective intellect which presupposes rationality: Rationality is inseparable from theory and both are articulated in the scientific method. We argue that a true alternative to rational choice must therefore, be in effect, an alternative to the scientific method, which as Heideggar pointed out, is itself the "theory of the real". The paper therefore, explores the essentiality of rationality in the modern conceptualization of theory and argues the impossibility of any modern theory to escape from subjective rationality of science insofar as it remains a theory - a theory of the real. So far as the scientific method is not simply a method, but the modern "theory of the real," constructed in the aftermath of Cartesian and Kantian Copernican Revolution, any theory of science, whether relative to the "social" or the "natural," qua theory, is necessarily scientific, methodic and turns on subjective rationality. Therefore, the distinction among competing theories of social science on the basis of rational choice and mathematical formalization have but little validity. We argue in this paper that any distinction worth making in epistemology of science should be between the primeval "theoria" of the pre-Cartesian and pre-Kantian metaphysics of being and the post-Cartesian and post-Kantian epistemology of science.

Keywords: Rational Choice, Scientific Method, Social Science, Theory

JEL Classification: B00, B20, B40

Suggested Citation

Adi, Bongo C. and Amaeshi, Kenneth and Nnodim, Paul, Revisiting the Rational Choice and Rationality Debate in the Social Sciences: Is Theory Possible Without Rationality?. International Journal of Interdisciplinary Social Sciences, Vol. 1, No. 6, pp. 27-38, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=989089

Bongo C. Adi (Contact Author)

Lagos Business School ( email )

Pan-Atlantic University
KM 22, Lekki-Epe Expressway
Lagos, Lagos State
Nigeria

HOME PAGE: http://www.lbs.edu.ng

University of Tsukuba ( email )

Tsukuba University , Ibaraki Ken
Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8573, Ibaraki 3050006
Japan

Kenneth Amaeshi

University of Edinburgh Business School ( email )

29 Buccleuch Place
Central Area
Edinburgh, Scotland EH8 9JS
United Kingdom

HOME PAGE: http://https://www.business-school.ed.ac.uk/about/people/738/Kenneth/Amaeshi

Cranfield University - School of Management ( email )

Bedfordshire, MK43 0AL
United Kingdom

Paul Nnodim

Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts ( email )

United States

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
426
Abstract Views
2,897
rank
95,738
PlumX Metrics