Appearance of Impropriety: Deciding When a Judge's Impartiality 'Might Reasonably Be Questioned'

48 Pages Posted: 28 Jun 2007

Abstract

This Article calls for both the ABA and the states to review their Codes of Judicial Conduct in order to: (1) add ethical duties not currently addressed, such as a black-letter judicial duty to disclose any known disqualifying circumstances to counsel and parties; (2) broaden existing duties like the judge's duty to inform himself or herself about personal and family financial holdings; and (3) consider new disqualifying conditions to reclassify general appearance of partiality situations as specific per se grounds for recusal.

Part I examines the Codes' standards relating to the appearance of impropriety, the accompanying Code commentary, waiver of disqualifying situations, and a comparison with attorneys' ethics rules about the appearance issue. Part II looks at judicial approaches to the appearance of impropriety, including its rationale, judicial disclosure of possible grounds for the existence of a negative appearance, the presumption of impartiality and the reasonable person standard by which appearances are measured, and whether an ethical violation for negative appearances requires a remedy such as a new trial or is merely harmless error. Part III studies the state court case law in nine factual contexts where the appearance of impropriety is often raised and discusses standards and criteria for each that should be added to the ABA Codes and commentary to assist judges, lawyers, and lay members of judicial conduct organizations in evaluating judicial disqualification or discipline.

Keywords: ethics, standards, code of judicial conduct

JEL Classification: K4, K00

Suggested Citation

Abramson, Leslie W., Appearance of Impropriety: Deciding When a Judge's Impartiality 'Might Reasonably Be Questioned'. Georgetown Journal of Legal Ethics, Vol. 14, No. 55, 2000. Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=996485

Leslie W. Abramson (Contact Author)

Louis D. Brandeis School of Law ( email )

Wilson W. Wyatt Hall
Louisville, KY 40292
United States

HOME PAGE: http://www.law.louisville.edu/

Register to save articles to
your library

Register

Paper statistics

Downloads
496
rank
52,962
Abstract Views
2,209
PlumX Metrics