Anchoring Vignettes and Response Consistency
33 Pages Posted: 3 Apr 2011
Date Written: February 2, 2011
Abstract
The use of anchoring vignettes to correct for differential item functioning rests upon two identifying assumptions: vignette equivalence and response consistency. To test the second assumption the authors conduct an experiment in which respondents in an Internet panel are asked to both describe their health in a number of domains and rate their health in these domains. In a subsequent interview respondents are shown vignettes that are in fact descriptions of their own health. Under response consistency and some auxiliary assumptions with regard to the validity of the experiment, there should be no systematic differences between the evaluation of these vignettes in the second interview and the self-evaluations in the first interview. They analyze data for five health domains: sleep, mobility, concentration, breathing and affect. Although descriptively the vignettes and the self-evaluations are similar for a number of domains, their nonparametric analysis suggests that response consistency is satisfied for the domain of sleep, while it indicates rejection of either the auxiliary assumptions or response consistency for the other domains of health. Parametric analysis suggests that the auxiliary assumptions may be most problematic. The analysis points at the need for a systematic experimental approach to the design of anchoring vignettes before using them in practice.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
The Ses Health Gradient on Both Sides of the Atlantic
By James W. Banks, Michael Marmot, ...
-
The Ses Health Gradient on Both Sides of the Atlantic
By James W. Banks, Michael Marmot, ...
-
Disease Prevalence, Disease Incidence, and Mortality in the United States and in England
By James W. Banks, Alastair Muriel, ...
-
Low Life Expectancy in the United States: Is the Health Care System at Fault?
By Samuel H. Preston and Jessica Y. Ho
-
Childhood Health and Differences in Late-Life Health Outcomes between England and the United States
By James W. Banks, Zoé Oldfield, ...
-
By Jonathan Gruber, Kevin S. Milligan, ...
-
Attrition and Health in Ageing Studies: Evidence from ELSA and HRS
By James W. Banks, Alastair Muriel, ...
-
Attrition and Health in Ageing Studies: Evidence from ELSA and HRS
By James W. Banks, Alastair Muriel, ...
-
Self Reported Disability and Reference Groups
By Arthur van Soest, Tatiana Andreyeva, ...
-
By Anirban Basu