Merit Motives and Government Intervention: Public Finance in Reverse
57 Pages Posted: 17 May 2000 Last revised: 16 Jul 2022
Date Written: May 2000
Abstract
A common view in public finance is that there is an efficiency-redistribution tradeoff in which distortions are tolerated in order to redistribute income. However, the fact that so much public- and private redistributive activity involves in-kind transfers rather than cash may be indicative of merit motives on the part of the payers rather than a preference for the well-being of the recipients. Efficiency-enhancing public policy in a merit good economy has the primary purpose of creating distortions and may only redistribute income from rich to poor in order to create those distortions the reverse of the conventional efficiency-redistribution tradeoff. We discuss why the largest programs on the federal and local level in the US including Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, and Public Schooling seem consistent with the reverse tradeoff rather than the classic one. Transfers are not lump sum in a merit good economy, and explicitly accounting for this when calculating tax incidence reduces the estimated progressivity of government policy. As one example, we calibrate the conventional life-cycle model to show how the amount of over-saving induced on the poor by Social Security hurts them at least as much as the progressive' benefits help them. When the distortions outweigh fiscal transfers in this manner, the classic efficiency-redistribution tradeoff cannot justify the program and the program is far less progressive than conventional analysis suggests.
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
The Political Economy of Social Security
By Georges Casamatta, Helmuth Gremer, ...
-
The Aging of the Population and the Size of the Welfare State
By Assaf Razin, Efraim Sadka, ...
-
The Aging Population and the Size of the Welfare State
By Assaf Razin, Efraim Sadka, ...
-
Social Security, Retirement, and the Single-Mindedness of the Electorate
-
Social Security, Retirement, and the Single-Mindedness of the Electorate
-
The Ageing Population and the Size of the Welfare State
By Assaf Razin, Efraim Sadka, ...