Academic Salaries and Public Evaluation of University Research: Evidence from the UK Research Excellence Framework

Abstract

We study the effects of public evaluation of university research on the pay structures of academic departments. A simple model of university pay determination shows how the pay-performance relationship can be explained by the incentives inherent in the research evaluation process. We then analyse the pay-performance relationship using data on the salary of all UK university full professors, matched to the performance of their departments from the 2014 UK government evaluation of research, the Research Excellence Framework (REF). A cross sectional empirical analysis shows that both average pay level and pay inequality in a department are positively related to performance. It also shows that the pay-performance relationship is driven by a feature of the research evaluation that allows academics to transfer the affiliation of published research across universities. To assess the causal effect of the REF on pay structure, we take advantage of the time dimension of our data and of quasi-experimental variation in the performance of academic departments generated by the research evaluation rules. Our results indicate that higher achieving departments benefit from increased future hiring and higher professorial salaries with the salary benefits of REF performance concentrated among the highest paid professors.

Keywords: Research evaluation, Research funding, Research Excellence Framework.

JEL Classification: D47, H42, I28, L30