Assessing the Stability of the Rule of Four on the U.S. Supreme Court
33 Pages Posted: 23 Apr 2008
Date Written: April 21, 2008
Abstract
Most research on the U.S. Supreme Court treats the Rule of Four as a fixed agenda-setting norm to which justices faithfully adhere. In this paper, we investigate the stability of the Rule of Four and suggest that there are circumstances under which the Rule of Four is violated. We argue that these violations are tied to the degree of ideological heterogeneity on the Court. Applying an existing theory of institutional stability (Barbera and Jackson, 2004), we connect agenda-setting procedures directly to the ideological heterogeneity of the justices on a given Court. We investigate hypothetical ideological configurations as well as the 1937-2006 terms of the Court and find that the Rule of Four is rarely stable. Only when a majority coalition, considering an ideologically incongruent lower court decision, possesses high intra-coalition ideological homogeneity, is the Rule of Four stable.
Keywords: U.S. Supreme Court, Rule of Four, institutional stability, minority rule institutions, norms
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation
Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?
Recommended Papers
-
The Case for Managed Judges: Learning from Japan after the Political Upheaval of 1993
-
The Industrial Organization of the Japanese Bar: Levels and Determinants of Attorney Incomes
By Minoru Nakazato, J. Mark Ramseyer, ...
-
By Vicki Schultz and Stephen Petterson
-
Strategic Judicial Decision Making
By Pablo T. Spiller and Rafael Gely
-
Congress and the Political Expansion of the United States District Courts
By John M. De Figueiredo, Gerald S. Gryski, ...
-
The Supreme Court and the Dig: An Empirical and Institutional Analysis
By Michael Solimine and Rafael Gely
-
The Japanese Judiciary: Maintaining Integrity, Autonomy and the Public Trust
-
By Tonja Jacobi
-
Medical Error as Reportable Event, as Tort, as Crime: A Transpacific Comparison
By Robert B Leflar and Futoshi Iwata