The Dynamics of Private Trademark Enforcement: The Case of Indian Pharmaceuticals

Abstract

This research explores the role of trademark litigation in protecting a brand against future trademark infringement in markets where government enforcement is weak. Litigation can convey to potential counterfeiters that a trademark-holding firm would sue upon entry. We explore this idea empirically in the context of pharmaceutical trademarks in India using the framework of a stylized theoretical model. We construct a database of trademarks and examine litigation activity by certain trademark-holders. Our findings indicate that litigation reduces subsequent infringement. Because litigation can be extremely costly for a trademark-holding firm, it is worthwhile only when it has legal advantages in pursuing cases. Not all trademark-holding firms have such legal advantages and are, therefore, better off surrendering to infringers and incurring a cycle of settlements with future infringement.

Keywords: Trademark infringement, trademark protection, reputation, litigation, intellectual property rights

JEL Classification: O34, L140, K42